Sourcing agent vs sourcing platform vs direct factory contact
Kavita Tewari
Direct contact is free and slow. Marketplaces are free and unfiltered. Sourcing agents typically take 5 to 10 percent of order value, or $500 to $10,000 as a fixed fee, and manage the work. Vetted matchmaking charges a flat fee for introductions and steps back. The right answer depends on your order size and how much of the work you want to own.
The four options
Direct | Marketplace | Sourcing agent | Vetted matchmaking | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Cost | Free | Free to browse | 5 to 10% of order, or fixed fee | Flat fee per search |
Who filters | You | Nobody | The agent | The service |
Who manages the order | You | You | The agent | You, mostly |
Speed to shortlist | Weeks | Hours | Days | Days |
Best for | Repeat orders, known category | Price discovery | Complex or high-value orders | First orders, unfamiliar category |
Direct factory contact
How it works. You find factories yourself, through trade shows, referrals, LinkedIn or search, and deal with them without an intermediary.
Cost: nothing beyond your own time.
When it is right:
You have done this before in this category
You already have a supplier and are adding a second
Your order is small enough that any percentage fee is disproportionate
You want the relationship itself, because that is what makes the second and third order easier
What it costs you in practice. Verification, which is a real workload. Checking registrations, cross-referencing names, reading certificates properly, commissioning an inspection, and asking the questions most first-time buyers do not know to ask. Budget two to four weeks per supplier you take seriously.
The genuine argument for it: long term, the relationship is the asset. A supplier who knows your product cuts a repeat order from five months to two. No intermediary gives you that, and some intermediaries stand between you and ever building it.
B2B marketplaces
How it works. IndiaMART, TradeIndia, Alibaba. Directories where suppliers list themselves and you contact them.
Cost: free to browse. Suppliers pay for placement.
When it is right:
Price discovery and understanding the range in a category
Finding candidates quickly at the start
Commodity products where specification is simple
What is actually wrong with them. Nothing is verified in the sense a buyer means. Anyone can list. Listings are self-written. And because suppliers pay for visibility, prominence reflects marketing spend rather than quality.
One manufacturer we interviewed told us plainly they are not on IndiaMART, JustDial or Sulekha, calling those shared leads that never convert because their pricing sits above market. They will not buy leads.
Read that carefully. Some of the better manufacturers are deliberately absent from the marketplaces, because the marketplace model selects for price competition. Marketplaces are not a complete view of the market, they are a view of the suppliers who bought placement.
Use them for discovery. Do not treat presence there as a signal in either direction.
Sourcing agents
How it works. An individual or firm in-country finds suppliers, negotiates, and manages production on your behalf. The level of involvement varies enormously.
What they cost
Model | Typical range |
|---|---|
Commission on order value | 3 to 15 percent, with most reputable full-service agents at 5 to 10 percent |
Fixed fee, simple sourcing | $500 to $1,500 |
Fixed fee, full project management | $3,000 to $10,000 |
Monthly retainer | $1,000 to $5,000 |
Hybrid | Small retainer plus reduced commission |
Inspection only | $200 to $500 per factory visit |
Larger volumes usually attract a lower percentage. Small complex trial runs sit at the top of the range, which is worth knowing if you are ordering 100 units of something difficult.
When an agent is right:
Higher-value orders where a percentage buys real management
Complex products needing someone physically present
You have no time and no intention of learning this
Multiple suppliers to coordinate for one product
What they are genuinely good at. Being there. Chasing production, catching problems in week two rather than week six, handling a factory that has gone quiet. Nothing on this page substitutes for someone in the same time zone who can turn up.
The structural weakness. A commission agent's income scales with your order value, not with your outcome. That is not an accusation, it is arithmetic, and good agents manage it honestly. But it means you should always ask how they are paid, and by whom.
The question worth asking: do you receive any payment from the factory as well as from me? Some do. It is not automatically disqualifying, and it is disqualifying if they will not answer.
Vetted matchmaking, which is what we do
How it works. A service interviews and verifies builders, then introduces you to ones that fit. You contract directly with the builder.
What we charge. ₹40,000 for a diagnostic, ₹9,000 per category for a scouted and vetted shortlist, or ₹50,000 a month for ongoing management.
We take no percentage of your order, and we are not paid by the builders we introduce. Which is a real structural difference and also the thing you should verify rather than take our word for.
When this is right:
A first order in a category you do not know
You want the verification done but intend to own the relationship
Your order is too small for a percentage-based agent to be interested
You want to know what was checked and what was not
The question nobody asks: what is each option paid to want
Features are easy to compare. Incentives explain behaviour.
Option | Paid by | Therefore wants |
|---|---|---|
Direct | Nobody | n/a. The work is yours |
Marketplace | Suppliers, for placement | More suppliers listed, more visibility sold. Not your outcome |
Commission agent | You, as a percentage | A completed order, and a larger one |
Fixed-fee agent | You, a set amount | To finish efficiently |
Vetted matchmaking | You, a flat fee | A good match, and to not stay involved |
Read your own row honestly. A commission agent wants your order to happen and to be big. A marketplace wants listings, not matches. And a flat-fee service like ours has no financial reason to stay engaged after the introduction, which is a genuine weakness dressed up as independence.
None of these incentives is disqualifying. Knowing which one you are dealing with tells you where to apply your own attention.
Which to choose
Situation | Sensible option |
|---|---|
First order, unfamiliar category, small volume | Vetted matchmaking, or direct with a paid verification audit |
First order, high value or complex product | Sourcing agent |
You know the category and have time | Direct |
Price discovery before deciding anything | Marketplace, then verify properly elsewhere |
Repeat order with a supplier who works | Direct, always |
Multiple suppliers, one product, tight timeline | Sourcing agent |
The combination most people actually want: a marketplace or a matchmaking service to build a shortlist, a paid verification audit at a few hundred dollars on the finalist, and then a direct relationship from there. That is usually cheaper than a percentage and stronger than either alone.
Questions to ask whoever you use
How are you paid, and by whom?
Do you receive anything from the factory as well as from me?
What exactly did you verify, and what did you not?
Do I contract with you or with the factory?
If this goes wrong in week six, what do you actually do?
Which categories can you not help with?
Or let us do it
Tell us what you are making and what volume, and we will tell you what level of checking it actually warrants.
See pricing and get in touch →
FAQ
How much does a sourcing agent in India charge?
Commission-based agents typically take 5 to 10 percent of order value, within an industry range of 3 to 15 percent. Fixed fees run $500 to $1,500 for simple sourcing and $3,000 to $10,000 for full project management. Monthly retainers run $1,000 to $5,000. Inspection-only visits are $200 to $500. Smaller and more complex orders sit at the higher end of the percentage range.
Do I need a sourcing agent to buy from India?
Not necessarily. Agents earn their fee on higher-value or complex orders needing someone physically present, or where you have no time to manage production. For a small first order, a verification audit at a few hundred dollars plus a direct relationship is often better value than a percentage of your order value.
Is IndiaMART reliable for finding manufacturers?
It is useful for price discovery and building an initial shortlist, and it verifies nothing in the sense a buyer means. Listings are self-written and prominence reflects paid placement. Note also that some stronger manufacturers deliberately avoid marketplaces because the model selects for price competition, so marketplace presence is not a signal in either direction.
What is the difference between a sourcing agent and a matchmaking service?
An agent typically manages the order for you and is often paid a percentage of it. A matchmaking service verifies and introduces builders, after which you contract with them directly, usually for a flat fee. An agent gives you management. Matchmaking gives you the relationship. Pick based on whether you want to own the supplier relationship long term.
How do I know if a sourcing agent is trustworthy?
Ask how they are paid and whether they also receive anything from the factory. Ask what they verified and what they did not. Ask which categories they cannot help with. Anyone who claims no limits is not describing a real business, and anyone who will not answer the payment question has answered it.
What is the cheapest way to source from India safely?
Use a marketplace or matchmaking service to build a shortlist, commission your own verification audit on the finalist at roughly $220 plus travel, then work directly. That combination usually costs less than a percentage-based agent and gives you a relationship you keep.
Let’s keep in touch.
Discover more. Follow us on Substack and Instagram.
